1970      Bill Roca (Football)
1973      Steve Zimmer (Football)
1986      Hilarie Cranmer (Women's Basketball)
1987      Hilarie Cranmer (Women's Basketball)
1987      Karen Canino (Softball)
1988      Sherry Sterbinsky (Softball)
1988      Kristine Pfanstiel (Volleyball)
1992      Crystal Boyd (Softball)
1993      Crystal Boyd (Softball)
1994      Crystal Boyd (Softball)
1996      Mike Polsky (Men's Tennis)
1998      Giovanni Carmazzi (Football)
2000      Alicia Smith (Softball)
2002      Arni Gunnarsson (Men's Soccer)
2002      Stefanie Rewitz (Volleyball)
2003      Arni Gunnarsson (Men's Soccer)
2003      Heather Brousseau (Softball)
2005      Nikola Djordjevic (Men's Tennis)
2005      Michael Todd (Men's Soccer)
2005      Chrissy Arnone (Women's Soccer)
2006      Nikola Djordjevic (Men's Tennis)
2006      Michael Todd (Men's Soccer)
2007      Sue Weber (Women's Soccer)
2010      Dana Bergstrom (Women's Soccer)
2010      Tiffany Yovino (Women's Soccer)
2011      Lou Ruggirello (Wrestling)
2012      Steve Bonanno (Wrestling)