In 2006 Hofstra lacrosse had its best season in program history. What was it like to coach and be a part of that 17-win team?
We had this incredible collection of seniors that really set the tone for the group. It was John Keysor, Tim Treubig, Rob Bonaguro, and John Orsen, and these guys were tough as nails, they loved each other, and they loved being at Hofstra. That was always the common theme when you get a group of guys that loved the place they were at – they loved Hofstra and everything about it – and they loved each other, and they were very coachable.
We were also very good across the field. We had Athan Ianucci, we had Tommy Dooley as a freshman, and Chris Unterstein was playing the best lacrosse of his life and was a Tewaaraton Award finalist. Defensively, we had Brett Moyer, Julian Watts, Kevin Unterstein, Ryan Kelaher, and those guys were good players as individuals but the whole was greater than the parts. Nobody cared about who got the credit; it was a classic story of them wanting to be successful together. We had a lot of chemistry with that team to go along with the talent, and that chemistry was the difference in games being maybe 14-6 instead of 8-6.
Nick Colleluori was on the squad and was diagnosed with cancer during that 2006 season. What was that like for you to see this walk-on freshman going through that ordeal?
That fall we had played North Carolina in a fall tournament at Stony Brook and I remember Nick being fearless when the ball was on the ground, trying to run through a ground ball and make contact. It was a Saturday morning at 10:30 in the morning or something, and that was my first real impression of Nick watching him compete. And then when his mom calls and tells us they have the diagnosis and she asked if we could meet with him outside his classroom, which I did. And we soon met in my office and Nick didn’t flinch; he was like ‘alright, I’m going home and we’re going to take care of this.’ And there was very little emotion, very little time for sympathy. It was time for confidence and an ‘I’m going to take care of it’ attitude.
In the springtime, we wanted to honor him. His nickname was “Fathead”, so somebody came up with the Fathead stickers, and when he either watched the film or if he was well enough to come to the game, his job was to hand out the stickers after the game to the players who deserved a sticker. It was a really cool time in that team’s development, because of his role on the team, and keeping him engaged with the program. The stickers were for hustle or tough plays, not goals or being the star of the team. It was for the kinds of plays that Nick was known for making. And the guys wore those stickers on the back of their helmets with a tremendous amount of pride.
Then when I left, I felt a little disconnected. I kind of felt like I had run out on him and I felt guilty. I was in touch with Seth [Tierney], his brother Michael and the family, and I had talked to Nick a couple weeks before his passing, and I remember that last conversation. Those are cherished conversations between me and him. The funeral was incredible; we packed that church with all the people that he touched in his short time. It was an incredible testament to his personality, his family, and being involved in sports. His high school football and lacrosse teammates, classmates, everyone he knew at Hofstra came to be there. It was really an incredible outpouring of love for his parents and his family.